AdvertiseDonate
Sunday, November 15, 2026Local news for the Skagit Valley, Washington.

Washington Supreme Court to Review Edmonds Tree Removal Dispute

The state high court will examine a lawsuit challenging Edmonds' tree replacement requirements after lower courts issued conflicting rulings on the property owner's claim.

By Andre Williams ·

Illustration for: Washington Supreme Court to Review Edmonds Tree Removal Dispute
Illustration generated for this article, not a news photograph.

The Washington State Supreme Court has agreed to hear a legal dispute concerning the city of Edmonds' tree regulations, according to recent court documents. The high court accepted the case on Friday, marking a significant escalation in a property rights battle that has spanned several years. This move follows an earlier decision by the Washington State Court of Appeals, which had dismissed the lawsuit as moot earlier this year.

The controversy originated in 2022 when Edmonds resident Nathan Rimmer applied for a permit to construct a single-family home on a vacant lot. His proposed building plans necessitated the removal of a dogwood tree located on the property. Before the city could finalize its decision on the permit, city staff mandated that Rimmer develop a plan to replace the removed tree. Additionally, they required him to dedicate a portion of the land to plant two extra trees as compensation.

Rimmer challenged these requirements in 2023, filing a lawsuit against the city. He alleged that the tree replacement mandate was unconstitutional. The dispute progressed to the Snohomish County Superior Court, where a judge ruled in January 2024 that the city's mandate was indeed unconstitutional. The legal proceedings continued with the same judge determining in December 2024 that the city was liable for financial damages accumulated during the litigation. The court also ordered the city to approve Rimmer's permit, a decision the city chose to appeal. The issue of whether the city would ultimately have to pay damages was scheduled to be resolved after the appeal process concluded.

While the legal battles unfolded, the underlying property transaction moved forward. In April 2024, the city approved Rimmer's building permit. Shortly after receiving approval, Rimmer sold the property. The new owner proceeded to build the home without being required to replace the original dogwood tree. Meanwhile, the city took steps to modify its own rules, updating its tree code in October 2025 to alter the procedures governing tree removal.

The appellate court's dismissal of the case in 2025 cited a lack of effective relief available to either party. The panel noted that Rimmer should have sought damages through the Land Use Petition Act rather than the current path. They concluded that the court could no longer provide meaningful relief to both the city and the property owner given the changed circumstances.

Brian Hodges, an attorney with the Pacific Legal Foundation, represented Rimmer in the lower courts. The Pacific Legal Foundation is a conservative nonprofit law firm. In May, Hodges filed a motion requesting the appellate court to reconsider its dismissal. After that motion was denied, he filed a petition with the State Supreme Court to bring the case to the highest level of the state judiciary.

In a press release issued on Tuesday, Hodges emphasized the impact of the city's initial stance on his client. He stated that the city's refusal allowed them to keep Rimmer from building on his own land for nearly two years. Hodges argued that property owners deserve compensation when the government delays permit approval based on an unconstitutional demand, even if the government eventually backs down following court intervention.

The city of Edmonds did not immediately respond to a request for comment regarding the Supreme Court's decision to hear the case. The outcome of this appeal could have broader implications for how local governments handle tree preservation mandates and property development disputes in Washington State.

Originally published by News Media House

More News · Edmonds news · Report a business · Got a Story?

Get Skagit Chronicle in your inboxLocal news for the Skagit Valley, Washington. Free, a few times a week, unsubscribe any time.

Get Skagit Chronicle in your inboxLocal news for the Skagit Valley, Washington. Free, a few times a week, unsubscribe any time.